The Most Vexatious Question in Life
This experience called life is foredoomed from the start as death is the earthly result for all of us. Of course being a sports star is foredoomed as all athletes lose their excellent athletic talent over time. Only an idiot would insist if they can’t be a star for life, then the hell with it. Nobody gets out of this world alive, any Heaven not withstanding. Even if there is a heaven, clearly it will be nothing like this world we have lived in for such a minuscule period of evolutionary time.
I often am grateful for the time and place I picked to live my life. Of course I didn’t pick it, but so many important unearned gifts in life have enabled me to be one of the affluent—living a life of modern comforts. Every time I ride a bus in Chicago, or a city transit train, or come in contact with those not living an affluent life, it seems a tad unfair so many things have gone my way, while for many less fortunate, life seems virtually a trap, a dead ended street to nothingburgerness..
Recently in the doctor’s office I was asked how I felt about my shoulder injury three months after it happened. In other words, what was my mental state with limited range of motion and the pain associated with healing process? I stated the truth: At 76 years of age I will take the shoulder problem over a heart condition, Alzheimer’s, degenerative muscle disease, diabetes, cancer, a stroke, and so on. My doctor, who knows me quite well, said he was glad it was not my legs since I walk so far so often. He’s right, when I can’t get around with my 3-4 hrs meandering around in nature and city areas— my most valued activity—-outside writing musings, such a fate would certainly leave my mental state dangerously wounded.
The mental state which drives my terminational years is mostly just a lot of gratefulness, not personal pride or money or property, or power over others, or popularity. It is not possible, nor necessary, to be everyone’s cup of tea. In a world where diversity is reality, no one can be all things to all people. All that we can achieve, to varying degrees, is to ensure we are not the reason some one else is kept back in life, blocked from any successes in their life.That includes political votes. So if someone doesn’t really like me, that is ok, providing they cannot claim I prevented them from having a better life. That is the basis on which I judge myself in relation to others. What the hell, it seems fair enough. On the flip side, it is important not to force ourselves on others who prefer some distance, for whatever reason. All we can do is try to be right and fair as dictated by the Golden Rule.
With all this in mind the most vexing question, at least in my small world, becomes one of why there is so much tragedy in the lives of so many? 75 million refugees across the globe, huddled like cattle, waiting for food that is about the same quality as cattle feed. I have sumptuous meals every day, these refugees never have a sumptuous meal. Daily some manage to endure, but in most cases for what? Many will just die, as unrememberable nobodies. It is not just refugee problems, but senseless violence is everywhere now, even in the wealthiest country of the world where we have 25% of all the prisoners in the world in our jails. Our urban, suburban, rural ghettoes aren’t shrinking, but growing at an exponential rate. Almost all of these unfortunate souls are out of sight for the most part (until they riot), essentially gated off from the more affluent world around them.
I have known students, like 20 years old, who have never been, except for school, more than a mile from their low quality neighborhood. The inhabitants of such ghettoes are considered by most as the dregs of society, responsible themselves for their environment and all the tragedies which arise in such ghettoes. Maybe it was the work environment during much of my life, where I was exposed daily to students whose problems of varied sorts sensitized me to these less fortunate souls existing in such large numbers. Had I been exposed to the same environmental situations, I would have most likely been dead-ended in life. It really would be a stretch to say that I ‘earned’ my modest successes. Therein lies the most vexatious question in life. If we hardly earned so much of our successes by ourselves, nor often earned the situations in which we were raised, then all these millions suffering across our globe, why must they suffer so? At what point in life did I change from a relative arrogant self serving Trumpish person to a more philosophical and realistic appraiser of this whole thing called success? In my case I really can’t say much of anything was handed to me outside of important things like my environment, time in history, and genetics—but I can say that it always seemed to be others who pushed me into situations on which I would have otherwise passed. There was, to be honest, nothing very much cuddly or handsome or brilliant, or overly friendly about me. In fact, my goal, from early in life was to be a hermit. Actually, for all my life I have been part hermit. I have always had a good size cabal of acquaintances, supporters from a distance, and endless partners in personal battles over this or that, or endless varied persons to be defended in their time of distress, but hardly anyone was what most people would term ‘tight’ with me. Many of my most trusted friends were animals and nobodies in life. It is always in the eyes: a pet can convey trust through their eyes and wounded humans can do this too. I have always been a sucker for eyes that convey hopelessness, desperation, sadness, innocence, and so on, right down the list of depressing emotional states. It bothers me to see suffering and injustices. It just does and has been an albatross around my neck most of my life.
Here is a good point to address the obvious. I use much of my own experiences as explanations for some musing topics. I reckon it validates that perhaps I am way too introspective and self exposing of my inner thoughts via many musings. Like who the hell cares what I personally think? Very few people have such a weird hobby as to write lengthy musings on so many topics. But I cannot express the thoughts of others based on the experiences of others for them. So, naturally, my musings are personal in nature. The best anyone can obtain from my own musings is food for thought. I do not have the remotest belief that my musings will change anything. The evolutionary process does not depend on any individual of any species to determine direction. Like I often say, ‘if Lincoln had not engineered the end of slavery in the United States, someone else would have down the road.’
I recently, by invitation, attended a Board room meeting at the Willis Tower, where a volunteer Medical Doctor for Doctors Without Borders reported on his recent stint in Syria along with medical technicians from the Sudan and Congo. I rarely attend gatherings of most any sort but this presentation intrigued me. While it bothers me to see suffering and injustices, even a gun to my head would not give me the impetus to go to such places engulfed in danger, primitive living conditions, and round the clock medical suffering day after day. One young gal I had seen before at someone’s house a couple of years ago. She remembered me, or so she claimed, and we chatted a bit again, and she has just started Medical School at the Univ. of Wisconsin, where I myself received a PH.D. in physiology way back in the late 60’s. She is a rather pretty gal with an outgoing and pleasant disposition, the kind of person who could easily spend her life in material comfort in a safe environment and loving family. Yet she continually returns to these forsaken areas mired in military conflict. These volunteers can only stay a limited number of months due to the extreme stress. Yet the locals are stuck in the same kind of stress decade after decade. Modern weaponry can leave nothing but rubble and death for vast areas.
I keep asking how can she do this? She is very soft spoken, cheerful, and all I can detect is that she derives contentment from helping those with the greatest needs right smack among them in their own environment. Death obviously doesn’t deter her, and she sure has seen death up close in the most devastating and hopeless ways. Donald Trump has had everything dumped into his lap since birth, and yet he is hopelessly mad at everything and everyone around him. This gal has no material wealth and is at peace and contented about her mission to help those in such dire situations, not just via monetary donations, but by helping them on their own turf at great personal risk to herself. When the call comes, she just packs up and shows up all by herself ready to join the front line of medical defense for these sorry-assed victims who just live at the wrong place at the wrong time.
While I admire the end results of the evolutionary process governed by the laws which God Himself created, I cannot adjust to the tragedies so many humans suffer in so many ways in so many places. Less complicated species do not have the mental capacity to so fully understand death, and pain, and consequences—but humans do. I suppose no pain, no gain certainly applies to the evolutionary process, but this pain is not evenly distributed. We are not all paying an equal price for this evolutionary process even though, in the end, we all die. Death is the great leveler. “That could be me” is certainly a sense that all of us have had many times during our lives. There seems to be no comprehensible answer to this vexing question, so no matter how well things may go for me in life, that vexing question is always right there, side by side with any degree of contentedness with my own life.
Perhaps God (however one envisions God) is not omnipotent and also has limitations. According to Walter Kaufmann, an American philosopher, it boils down to this: “is God unable to prevent suffering, and thus not omnipotent? or is he able and not willing it and thus not merciful? And is he just?” If God won’t save innocent lives in Syria, and that gal from Doctors Without Borders will, something doesn’t seem right here. Maybe our perceptions of perfection are simply illusionary since perfection would leave no excitement to those living in such a world. Sameness is not mentally stimulating. Maybe God had a choice, let his created laws lead to an evolutionary process which is unpredictable, except advance would be interrupted with long periods of stagnation or reversals until progress once again proceeded. If this were the case, then we either have no evolutionary progress and there are no individual tragedies, or there is evolutionary progress with tragedies abounding based on circumstance, diversity, and luck—with individual pain and tragedies as all the variables sort themselves out. One thing seems clear enough—God isn’t singling out any specific humans for pain and tragedy, but lets the process itself generate the victims and the winners. All individuals have is a chance to achieve some individual contentment, based on the Golden Rule. Thus when it comes to individual justice, assistance, and progress we are dependent on each other through the Golden Rule. Through the evolutionary process, God has given humans the means to maximize contentment for the maximum number of people. Clearly He does not do it Himself thru prayer by interfering with His created laws which govern the evolutionary process.
If I stop here it is only because I have reached a dead end. It is what it is. To the extent we have helped others along the way to achieve some contentedness in their lives, we can sop up some contentedness for ourselves. Those are happiest and most contented who have helped others along the way, especially those least fortunate. No wonder that gal from Doctors Without Borders seems so calm and cheerful—those who do the most for the less fortunate reap rewards via a mental state the rest of us cannot hope to match. She would probably say to those like me “The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself”. But as I once replied to a Doctor, “How does one learn not to worry?” Nope, no chance I am putting on my hat and coat and heading to Syria, no matter how many supportive letters might be written by others to send me there. Smile. When it comes to the Golden Rule we are not all meritoriously equal. But we all can, through concerted effort, do better with this rule and consequently achieve a greater degree of contentment for ourselves and others in life.
A lot of our good deeds are minor but can still generate contentment for us. Sheebiejiebee, my cat, was a feral cat picked up by animal control when she was rather young. It took her a good 5 years before she accepted that I could be trusted. One remnant of her feral life is that she doesn’t like to sleep at night in the open, like on top of a bed. She prefers to open a closet door and sleep in there all night where she feels more secure. I figure that is from her feral life existence when young. She would sleep on top of some old work pants lying on the closet floor. A few days ago I finally bought her a nice soft round sleeping bed, a perfect fit for her. She absolutely loves the damn thing. And that made me contented as I still babble away to her that ‘You must be very special to have such a nice bed to sleep in.” It doesn’t make any difference that she ignores my babble—I did a good deed and it makes me contented. The point is that there are endless opportunities via the Golden Rule to give and receive contentment. Now if I could just figure out where to bury all the bodies. Time to end this, deterioration is setting in.