Big League ‘Welfare Queens’
Back in the Reagan years I felt strongly that ‘us’ taxpayers were supporting a huge cabal of lazy, shiftless, irresponsible—often criminal leeches dependent on the more meritorious citizens of our society, which of course included myself. Certainly these kind of leeches do exist but, with a bit more life experience behind me, I realize some of the biggest welfare queens are not from that cabal of lazy, shiftless, irresponsible, often criminal citizens living in our poverty ghettoes. I may not be the among the biggest ‘welfare queens’ but I have gotten more for nothing, unearned welfare than those getting food stamps, unemployment checks, etc in our poverty ghettoes. Then again I am a hard working responsible citizen who deserves any welfare I get. But it gets confusing—welfare is something for nothing. Since I have always earned a decent amount why would I need something for nothing?
Something for nothing—unearned income— has grown to mammoth amounts of money in the last 50 or so years. Naturally, so has our debt at every level. Something for nothing is not always unwarranted unless we have no ethical nature. We don’t encourage birth and then leave the resulting child on their own unless we are hard core ‘right to lifer’s’ —their concern stops after childbirth.
If I total all the unearned, something for nothing welfare I personally have gotten in my life it is a bit staggering. For the first 18 years of my life I was on genetic welfare and the spin of the wheel of luck. I never earned my place to live, the era in which I lived, the schools I attended, my health care, the food I ate, my secure environment in which to live my formative years, my physical characteristics, who my parents were, and so on. I did quite well, am sure some did better, and many a lot worse.
After my formative years, the early productive years were a tad rough but even then I began to receive unearned somethings for nothing. I got a draft deferment during the Vietnam War because I was in graduate school. That was a nice unearned gift from the government since even though I was, for sometime, a rabid supporter of that war, it was ok by me to let others do the killing. That was a huge embarrassment later on for both me and my political sage Barry Goldwater. I guess we both matured with age. We killed Vietnamese like flies. We lost and I am not aware Vietnam has been any security threat to us. What 35,000 American Soldiers died for would be hard to justify.
I accidentally ended up teaching in a State University. That turned out, over the years, to be accidentally brilliant. The pay itself was modest but decent, job security great, vacation time great, pensions great, health insurance great, and so on. This all came as part of the job, a pleasant form of earned income. When much of this began to evaporate for others in private industry, including some salaries, health care benefits, and pensions, I was protected by the courts. I really didn’t earn this select protection but gobbled up all this unearned special protection like a pig at a trough.
I am of course now retired with a decent pension, but roughly half of my income comes from financial speculation, mostly in stocks. There is nothing inherently wrong with shuffling papers around for speculative purposes, but let’s just be real here and admit that the government taxing me less, substantially less, for that earned income compared to the earned the income some other worker earns from pushing a wheelbarrow around all day—well, that’s government welfare directed specifically at people like me. And yes, the day this ‘welfare’ is taken away from me I will no doubt squeal like a pig too.
Even though relatively healthy for my age, I have had some expensive medical procedures performed, albeit the expense was not always matched by the seriousness of the problem. Everything is expensive in medical care these days, in part because there are so many available options to treat medical problems. Gone are the days when most people had their heart attack or stroke, etc. and simply died. For me, this is more government welfare since I am sure I never paid enough in health insurance over the years to pay for it all. This alone amounts to a healthy sum of money.
I reckon that one of my biggest ‘something for nothing’ gifts has been no expensive hobbies. Of course this gift didn’t come from the ‘government’, but still it is an unearned genetic gift. I certainly did not earn this part of my nature. Having no expensive hobbies I can well afford to maintain a charitable gift fund (FANAFI), and give yearly grants to charitable organizations of my choice. But the government helps me out here too. I don’t pay a lot in taxes, under 10% because these grants are deductible expenses. That’s nice, but it also means I don’t have to pay my share of taxes to maintain roads, military preparedness, deal with national disasters, etc. Other taxpayer’s will have to make up the difference. Thank you all.
I, like so many other citizens, have always been annoyed that my tax money was being used so often to pay those who were leeches on society. My hard self-earned money was being welfared out to useless unproductive citizens, especially those in huge urban, rural, or suburban ghettoes. Reality often annoys me and never more so than the following: For my first 18 years I was a welfare recipient dependent upon my parents. They were able to be generous enough. Then in my productive years the government helped me out a lot as depicted above. I retired at 56, pretty young, but quite legal enough to do, and let the government pay me a decent pension for the rest of my life. I have already lived 19 more years on that pension, a gift from the government. Let’s say I live to be 86 years old. That’s 18 plus 30 which is 48 years as a ‘welfare queen’ of some sort. In fact I am getting back far more than I ever put in. I suppose I am a nice enough guy, decent citizen, and personally I kind of admire myself just as much as others admire themselves. I certainly am not ghetto trash. Not even trailer park trash, not even illegal immigrant trash, etc. Most of them can’t even remotely match me as a ‘welfare queen’, not by hundred’s of thousand’s of dollars.
And guess what, lest everyone hate me——I am no where near one of the biggest welfare queens. We have huge genetic cabals in this country who live off inheritances. Welfare is welfare. Inheritance is an unearned gift. It is a form of welfare. Then there are the Trumps of this world. They inherit a lot of money. We all know the more money you have to start with, the easier it is to amass even more money via all kinds of government tax loopholes, tax credits, tax shelters and so on. So one can attract investors to build some luxurious building, squirrel a lot of that money away so the government can’t touch it, then declare bankruptcy and leave contractors and investors holding the bag. You make a small fortune and others lose a small fortune. It all evens out but that is welfare. A really evil kind of welfare. It is not really earned money at all. When 2-5 percent of citizens own 90 percent of the wealth in this country they certainly never earned this right to accomplish this.
Even Bill Gates, who is genuinely a nice guy and willingly gives back millions of his financial wealth to good causes, earned that vast wealth by a capitalistic system with no limits. Capitalism is a great system but not when it has no limits. In a just capitalistic society, excess wealth earned by any individual, through steep progressive tax rates or upon death, goes back into the society from which it was extracted so that it levels the playing field for a new generation to compete for that wealth. In a just society all children have a level playing field, with good schools, good teachers, good health care, a safe neighborhood, and opportunities for employment when of age. Society is responsible for all this. We have failed miserably at this and are now paying a tremendous cost when the young of these gated off ghettoes grow up and behave in manners which are anti-social and irresponsible. Everyone knows you can’t screw up the formative years of children and expect them to become responsible productive members of society. Nevertheless, for the most part, we blame the victims and exonerate our own personal selves by proudly making it clear that we, personally, have never done a thing to hurt any of them. Probably true in most cases, in fact most of us have never even been in any of these ghettoes ourselves. But collectively, we have all failed them. Society as a whole, and whatever government represents that society, is responsible for what kind of communities exist under it’s domain. But mostly we manage to blame the victims—disgusting creatures who should know better.
By chance I learned a lot about the environment which exists in our urban ghettoes since many students at the University where I taught came from such ghetto environments. I was not in direct contact with the incorrigible, damaged beyond repair, youth of such an environment. It is probably simply too late to undo what their formative years did to their mindset. Young people need healthy safe civilized direction in their formative years. There are many families of some ilk who, although living in an urban ghetto, understand the value of education and have strong ethical values. Their children were often the most honest, dependable, cooperative, industrious students to be found anywhere. Usually the parents or parent or guardian who raised them were of of similar traits.
But the minute these students step outside their ‘home’ there are few, if any, level playing fields. The schools are overcrowded and ill equipped. The teachers are not very good (the best teachers rarely race to teach in such schools). The family, including the kids, had little or no health care. They lived in an apartment with bars on the windows and doors. They had no safe place to play. Money to feed the family or to pay the rent was almost always in crisis mode. These kids showed up to a University far behind those kids from more affluent schools. It is impossible not to admire their determination to escape the ghetto via education. But they had to work a 40 hr a wk job, despite any student loan, to help their families survive. Since unemployment rate in their neighborhood would be around 60-70%, this job would often require a 40-60 minute ride each way on public transportation to work. Sometimes they had ongoing medical or dental problems which needed attention but they had no money for such purposes. The parent or parents often were working two jobs, and still were paid so little that surviving became a monumental task. They came from high schools where their behavior and personalities were so appreciated by their teachers that they would get good grades on that basis alone. Their academic skills needed to catch up to students from more affluent communities, and yet the best years to develop these skills had already passed. Only with amazing effort, and stress, and external help from others can they ever hope to graduate and then, almost invariably, they barely are able to do so. These young people have potential talent to be highly successful, but no way can they catch up and then reach their potential in four years with all the responsibilities they have on their shoulders. So with little other choice they become mailmen, bus drivers, technicians of some sort, etc. and settle for at least something better than living in an urban ghetto. I suppose that is success of some sort, but nothing like the success they would have been able to achieve had they not lived in one of our ghettoes. Even sadder, they are a small percentage of the young people who grew up in such a ghetto. The other young people, far more numerous, will reproduce and create even bigger ghettoes, and the band marches on. These admirable parents and students are labeled ‘welfare queens’—lazy shiftless, irresponsible dregs of society. If we could just stop food stamps, rent subsidies, medical handouts, unemployment benefits, and keep minimum wages down, then magically these ghettoes will disappear and everything will be better. This absurdity is often the economic plan of many politicians to reduce the national or state debt. Brilliant.
There is no question but that huge amounts of something for nothing is given to vast numbers of citizens in our society. Oddly and unfairly enough, this something for nothing given to the affluent far exceeds the amount given to the poorest in our worst ghetto areas. In an ideal society all children would be given a level playing field for education, health care, safe neighborhoods, job opportunities, and have volunteer grandparents, uncles, aunts, and mentors where needed. No child born in a difficult situation should be left to fend for him/her self. That is not something for nothing at all—rather it is a collective responsibility for all in society as a means for their society to survive over time. Almost all major societies in history have collapsed because of extreme income inequality and/or an empire too vast and too expensive to maintain.
If many of us want to see a clear picture of a big-league welfare queen we just need look in the mirror. I know, in my case it couldn’t have happened to a nicer person.